VISUAL DIARY OF ESPA
Below are images with captions that captures the #ACE_EPSA team’s reflections on different elements, stages, and findings of the ESPA project. Be sure to follow the hashtag #ACE_ESPA on Twitter to keep up to date with the latest from the #ACE_ESPA project.
FINAL REFLECTIONS ON OUR ESPA PROJECT
By co-managers Dr Yvonne Erasmus and Dr Laurenz Langer
Our year-long #ACE_ESPA project has now officially come to an end. It has been an exciting and challenging year of work, and we’re very grateful to have been able to engage with a new body of evidence. This is our final blog post as part of our project, and as we look back over the year (and forward to the next), we reflect on three things: what we have achieved, what we have learned, and what we are excited about.
What have we achieved?
- Project outputs
As part of this project, we’ve produced an interactive evidence map, two thematic rapid evidence assessments, one rapid evidence assessment on tools to support environmental decision-makers, and one rapid evidence assessment on research methods. After completing five pieces of work, four associated reports, and one (so far) academic paper, it goes without saying that it has been a busy year!
- Relationships
We have been very fortunate to work with incredible decision-makers in Africa who have participated with enthusiasm, are committed to evidence-informed decision-making, and have shared with us the amazing strides being made to ensure that environmental decision-making in Africa is evidence-informed.
Without our government partners Kiruben Naicker and Mapula Tshangela from the South African Department for Environmental Affairs, the success that has been #ACE_ESPA would not have been possible.
What have we learned?
- Growing evidence
Environmental evidence has a long history with a substantive evidence-base, but still some primary research needs exist. There is much space for young researchers to get involved in the production of primary research evidence that investigates the causal impact of interventions on poverty and ecosystems, both in Africa and beyond. Using the evidence map and the ESPA research plotted on the decision-making wheel would be a great place to understand the primary research needs. In addition, many areas for evidence synthesis remain where large bodies of primary research exists that have not been synthesized in a systematic manner.
What are we excited about?
- Continuing the conversation
Our ESPA project may have come to an end, but the conversations to be had regarding this evidence-base are going strong. We’re excited to engage with decision-makers across Africa about how they can use these project outputs in their decision-making. We’re also excited to share with research producers our experiences of carrying out this project the way in which we did.
To end, we thank our partners, team members, and funders: without you, the successful completion of this evidence synthesis project would not have been possible for the #ACEdreamteam.
December 2017: #ACE_ESPA wraps up with incredible outputs from 12 months of work!
-
- March 2017 – The #ACE_ESPA team grows
-
- April – We map all the ESPA research on the decision-making wheel to show the great contribution ESPA projects have made to diagnosing environmental and poverty challenges
-
- May – We map all the research on ecosystem services interventions and their impact on poverty in Africa
-
- June – Our #evidencemap is shared with our decision-maker colleagues from South Africa’s Department: Environmental Affairs who suggest we add an Indigenous Knowledge filter to the map
-
- July – We engage with decision-makers across Africa to hear what their priorities for our two thematic evidence syntheses are
-
- August – #ACE_ESPA co-manager Dr Yvonne Erasmus shares our #evidencemap with decision-makers at the South African Biodiversity and Evidence Indaba
-
- September – Dr Yvonne Erasmus shares #ACE_ESPA’s experience of engaging with decision-makers during the Global Evidence Summit in Cape Town
-
- December – #ACE_ESPA co-managers Dr Yvonne Erasmus and Dr Laurenz Langer at the ESPA Science conference in Edinburgh
September 2017: The #ACE_ESPA team attends the Global Evidence Summit in Cape Town, South Africa from 13 to 17 September
-
- ACE director, Professor Ruth Stewart, speaks at the first plenary on the difference that networks make to evidence use in Africa.
-
- #ACE_ESPA review team member – Charity Chisoro – networks with a fellow delegate at the Global Evidence Summit. The Summit brought together researchers from across the globe interested in evidence synthesis methodologies.
-
- September – Dr Yvonne Erasmus shares #ACE_ESPA’s experience of engaging with decision-makers during the Global Evidence Summit in Cape Town
-
- #ACE_ESPA review team members (Zafeer Ravat, Charity Chisoro, and Mary Opondo) participate in a workshop about how to persuade decision-makers to use research evidence.
September 2017: #ACE_ESPA investigates governance in protected areas in one of their rapid evidence assessments
-
- 2017.09.04 What is the impact of different governance structures in protected areas on ecosystem services and multidimensional poverty alleviation in Sub-Saharan Africa? This is the question asked by #ACE_ESPA’s first rapid evidence assessment. The emphasis of this question is on the governance of protected areas (PAs), which makes it essential to have an understanding of what a protected area is as well as the definition of governance. Good governance is a measure of how far certain principles and values are adhered to, as well as how custom-made it is to its particular setting. – Charity Chisoro
-
- 2017.08.28 IUCN defines a protected area as “a clearly defined geographical space, recognised, dedicated and managed, through legal or other effective means, to achieve the long-term conservation of nature with associated ecosystem services and cultural values.” What I found particularly interesting and very helpful was how they “unpack” this definition. There is a detailed explanation for each word and phrase and the use of examples as a way of further clarifying the concept. Governance is “a set of processes, procedures, resources, institutions and actors that determine how decisions are made and implemented.” It refers to principles, policies and rules regarding decision-making, all clearly relevant in the case of protected areas – Charity Chisoro
-
- 2017.09.06 Most people tend to use the concepts management and governance interchangeably because their assumption is that they are the same. However, I found it quite fascinating to gain an understanding that there is actually a difference between these two concepts. On one hand, management consists of the “means and actions” to achieve set goals (i.e. what you do in order to achieve particular goals). On the other hand, governance involves the aspect of who will be the decision maker and how they will implement decisions to meet the set objectives. It is also about the individuals who hold power, authority, responsibility and accountability. – Charity Chisoro
17 – 18 August 2017: Department: Environmental Affairs (DEA) Biodiversity and Evidence Indaba
The #ACE_ESPA project co-manager Dr Erasmus launched the evidence map on the links between interventions related to ecosystem services and poverty alleviation in Africa at the DEA Biodiversity and Evidence Indaba. Laurenz Langer – project co-manager – was active on Twitter, along with a number of ACE partners. Below are a selection of tweets from the day. – Natalie Tannous.
-
- August – #ACE_ESPA co-manager Dr Yvonne Erasmus shares our #evidencemap with decision-makers at the South African Biodiversity and Evidence Indaba
-
- 2017.06.12 Understanding the links between multidimensional poverty and water is important in addressing the challenges of diminishing water quality and quantities, to avert future crises. The discussions around water conservation should therefore focus on identifying innovative solutions for water conservation within local communities and raising awareness on importance of water in poverty reduction. – Mary Opondo
-
- July – We engage with decision-makers across Africa to hear what their priorities for our two thematic evidence syntheses are
-
- 2017.06.14 Engaging with literature on interventions and outcomes has enabled me to learn a lot regarding the ecosystems services and poverty alleviation. An important lesson that stood out for me was the dilemma that is faced regarding biodiversity conservation and poverty reduction. Poor people in the rural areas rely on firewood as a source of fuel but at the same time, they are required to conserve trees as a way of promoting sustainability. This left me with me a question: “what is the efficient way of conserving natural resources without disadvantaging the vulnerable?” #ACE_ESPA – Charity Chisoro
-
- 2017.06.03 A blog written #ACE_ESPA project co-manager Dr Yvonne Erasmus invites African decision-makers who are part of the Africa Evidence Network to vote for the most important of five environmental questions. The #ACE_ESPA team will use rapid evidence assessments to answer two thematic questions, the research for which will be drawn from the evidence map. – Natalie Tannous
-
- 2017.06.20 The progress thus far has led to a select few potential synthesis questions. Now we’re left with an important decision to make regarding the direction the #ACE_ESPA project will take! – Zafeer Ravat
April – May 2017 #ACE_ESPA engaging with Africa decision-makers using the interactive evidence interface
-
- June – Our #evidencemap is shared with our decision-maker colleagues from South Africa’s Department: Environmental Affairs who suggest we add an Indigenous Knowledge filter to the map
-
- 2017.05.19 The farmer got their first harvest and we, likewise got our first product of the project, which is the evidence map. The farmer is holding a bundle of their harvest and we have bundled together the literature in the form of an evidence map: our first victory as an ESPA team! #ACE_ESPA – Charity Chisoro
-
- May – We map all the research on ecosystem services interventions and their impact on poverty in Africa
-
- 2017.05.21 This image is a reflection of the various interventions and outcomes covered by the evidence map on ecosystem services and poverty alleviation in Africa: behind the scenes was the rigorous screening process of abstracts from articles and coding that resulted in the vibrant display of evidence. #ACE_ESPA – Mary Opondo
January – March 2017 First quarter of #ACE_ESPA ends with an evidence map!
-
- 2017.03.06 Before embarking on the development of the evidence map for the UJ-ESPA project, I expect the literature on the relationship between ecosystem services and poverty to be like this image: the services provided by nature go largely unnoticed although they are completely relied on. #UJESPA – Natalie Tannous.
-
- March 2017 – The #ACE_ESPA team grows
-
- 2017.04.13 The first stage of the ESPA project is complete – we have an evidence map! The next stage of the UJ-ESPA project is to consult with our decision-making partners on the map to set the four questions for synthesis. Exciting times! #UJESPA – Natalie Tannous
